I METADATI DI QUESTO DOI SONO STATI AGGIORNATI IL: 2024-01-10 22:40
Titolo completo
RIVISTA DI STORIA DELLA FILOSOFIA
Editore
FrancoAngeli
ISSN
0393-2516 (Rivista Stampata)
1972-5558 (Rivista Online)
Numero del fascicolo
1
Designazione del fascicolo
1
Data del fascicolo
2009
Titolo completo
Al nominalista non manca proprio nulla? La dispensabilitŕ dell'insieme vuoto in mereologia
Di (autore)
Prima Pagina
63
Ultima Pagina
73
Lingua del testo
Italiano
Data di publicazione
2009/03
Copyright
2009 FrancoAngeli srl
Introduzione o prefazione
- Quine's commitment to nominalism has always required set theory to be replaced by an ontologically less dubious tool for the analysis of predication, one that is usually ABSTRACT Rivista di storia della filosofia, n. 1, 2009 mereological in nature, akin to the Calculus of Individuals he and Goodman developed in a seminal paper on nominalism. The problem Quine himself always acknowledged as central in any such replacement arises with the mereological "translation" of numbers. I show here that Quine's proposed translation strategy, even when successful, raises even more serious issues since it requires mereology to supply a substitute for the empty set. After proving the indispensability, given Quine's translation, of such an entity, I demonstrate that an exact mereological replica of the empty set (the "null object") cannot be admitted without engendering contradictions. I conclude by discussing some paraphrases of the usual mereological axioms that prima facie might seem to be compatible with the null object and assessing their implausibility.