THIS DOI METADATA WAS LAST UPDATED: 2025-12-02 17:26
Full Title (French)
STUDI MEDIEVALI III SERIE
Publisher
FONDAZIONE CENTRO ITALIANO DI STUDI SULL'ALTO MEDIOEVO (CISAM)
ISSN
0391-8467 (Printed Journal)
Journal Volume Number
55
Journal Issue Number
1
Journal Issue Date
2014
Full Title (French)
La plenitudo potestatis dans le Breviloquium de principatu tyrannico (1339-1341) de Guillaume d’Ockham
By (author)
Number of Pages
63
First Page
101
Last Page
164
Language of text
French
Publication Date
2014
Copyright
2014 FONDAZIONE CENTRO ITALIANO DI STUDI SULL'ALTO MEDIOEVO (CISAM)
Main description (English)
In William of Ockham’s mature political works (1338-1347) and especially in the Breviloquium de principatu tyrannico (1339-1341), the plenitudo potestatis is the object of great attention, emphasized by the interpreters but never yet analyzed in relation to the long history of this concept and to its place in the Venerabilis Inceptor’s political writings. The present paper aims at filling this gap. After tracing its history, we move on to William’s analysis of the concept. We start by considering the definition that he proposes and the legal notions that it mobilizes, and then go on studying it in the Breviloquium, focusing on the argumentation at work across the entire political corpus. William’s refutation of plenitudo potestatis aims at providing a semantic explanation: the fullness of power as occasional temporal power doesn’t as such characterize the regular power of the Papacy. This position, very similar to that of Innocent III or Hostiensis, isn’t original and its interest for us is therefore mostly methodological. The thesis that we defend is that the definition of the power of the Papacy in the Breviloquium is directly linked, on a formal level, to the legal solutions suggested by Ockham to the dispute over evangelical poverty in his early political works (1332-1337).