THIS DOI METADATA WAS LAST UPDATED: 2025-07-30 15:49
Full Title
HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT AND POLICY
Publisher
FrancoAngeli
ISSN
2240-9971 (Printed Journal)
2280-188X (Online Journal)
Journal Issue Number
1
Journal Issue Designation
1
Journal Issue Date
2025
Full Title
Pantaleoni and Pareto on Labour Issues
By (author)
First Page
37
Last Page
57
Language of text
English
Publication Date
2025/06
Copyright
2025 FrancoAngeli srl
Main description
This essay provides a parallel review of Maffeo Pantaleoni's and Vilfredo Pareto's thoughts on labour issues. Despite noteworthy differences in their theoretical angles on labour, both Pantaleoni and Pareto had faith in the self-regulating function of labour markets. Pantaleoni's and Pareto's adherence to this neoclassicism-backed liberal creed in contradiction to the nature of capitalistic labour caused vicissitudes of their attitudes towards industrial relations. With changes in Italy's industrial relations, Pantaleoni and Pareto shifted from being sympathetic to antagonistic towards labour movements. They finally inclined to Fascism in the expectation that the Fascists could restore market-directed Italian capitalism by ruthlessly crushing workers' power. Thus, this essay illuminates strong affinities between Pantaleoni's and Pareto's thoughts on labour issues.
Unstructured Citation
Atti Parlamentari, Camera dei Deputati, CXLVIII, 2a tornata di martedì 18 giugno 1901, 5303-5349.
Unstructured Citation
Atti Parlamentari, Camera dei Deputati, XCV, 2a tornata di sabato 28 giugno 1902, 3691-3735.
Unstructured Citation
Augello M.M. and Michelini L. 1997. Maffeo Pantaleoni (1857-1924). Biografia scientifica, storiografia e bibliografia. Pensiero economico Italiano, 5, 119-206.
Unstructured Citation
Bellamy R. 1987. Modern Italian Social Theory: Ideology and Politics from Pareto to the Present. Cambridge, Polity Press.
Unstructured Citation
Bertolini A. and Pantaleoni M. 1892. Cenni sul concetto di massimi edonistici individuali e collettivi. Giornale degli economisti, 4, 285-323.
Unstructured Citation
Bini P. 1997. When Economics Talked to Society: The Life, Thought and Works. In Baldassarri M. (ed.) Maffeo Pantaleoni: At
the Origin of the Italian School of Economics and Finance. New York, St. Martin’s Press, 11-46.
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-349-14537-9_1
Unstructured Citation
Black R.D.C. (ed.) 1977. Papers and Correspondence of William Stanley Jevons, III, Correspondence 1863-1872. London and Basingstoke,
Macmillan.
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-349-00723-3
Unstructured Citation
Chauvel L. and Fitoussi J-P. 1997. Pareto and Pantaleoni: Parallel Lives and Secant Lives. In Baldassarri M. (ed.) Maffeo
Pantaleoni: At the Origin of the Italian School of Economics and Finance. New York, St. Martin’s Press, 155-175.
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-349-14537-9_4
Unstructured Citation
Cubbe G.d.G. 2024. Elites and Democracy: Vilfredo Pareto for Social and Political Sciences, 100 Years Later. In Adair-Toteff
C. (ed.) Vilfredo Pareto’s Contributions to Modern Social Theory: A Centennial Appraisal. Abingdon, Routledge, 79-95.
https://doi.org/10.4324/9781003305514-6
Unstructured Citation
De Rosa G. (ed.) 1984a. Vilfredo Pareto œuvres complètes, XXVIII, Lettere a Maffeo Pantaleoni 1890-1923, Volume primo, 1890-1896. Geneva, Librairie DROZ.
Unstructured Citation
De Rosa G. (ed.) 1984b. Vilfredo Pareto œuvres complètes, XXVIII, Lettere a Maffeo Pantaleoni 1890-1923, Volume secondo, 1897-1906. Geneva, Librairie DROZ.
Unstructured Citation
De Rosa G. (ed.) 1984c. Vilfredo Pareto œuvres complètes, XXVIII, Lettere a Maffeo Pantaleoni 1890-1923, Volume terzo, 1907-1923. Geneva, Librairie DROZ.
Unstructured Citation
Jevons W.S. 1957. The Theory of Political Economy. New York, Kelley & Millman.
Unstructured Citation
Marcoaldi F. 1980. Maffeo Pantaleoni, la riforma finanziaria e il governo fascista nel periodo dei pieni poteri, attraverso le lettere ad Alberto De’ Stefani. Annali della Fondazione Luigi Einaudi, 14, 609-665.
Unstructured Citation
Marshall A. 1961. Principles of Economics, Ninth (Variorum) Edition with Annotations by C.W. Guillebaud, Vol. I, Text. London, Macmillan.
Unstructured Citation
Mattei C.E. 2022. Operazione austerità: come gli economisti hanno aperto la strada al fascismo. Turin, Giulio Einaudi editore.
Unstructured Citation
Michelini L. 1998. Marginalismo e socialismo: Maffeo Pantaleoni (1882-1904). Milan, FrancoAngeli.
Unstructured Citation
Okada M. 2012. A Reappraisal of Jevons’s Thought on Labour. History of Economic Thought, 53(2), 21-40,
https://doi.org/10.5362/jshet.53.2_21
Unstructured Citation
Okada M. 2016a. Léon Walras’s Thoughts on Labour in His Trilogy: A Moulding of the Neoclassical Principle of Labour Exchange.
History of Economic Thought, 57(2), 25-45,
https://doi.org/10.5362/jshet.57.2_25
Unstructured Citation
Okada M. 2023. Conflict between Alfred Marshall’s Illumination of the Distinctiveness of Labour and His Neoclassicist Faith.
History of Economic Thought, 65(1), 52-74,
https://doi.org/10.5362/jshet.65.1_52
Unstructured Citation
Pantaleoni M. [1900] 1909. Il secolo ventesimo secondo un individualista. In Pantaleoni M. Scritti varii di economia, Serie seconda. Milan, Remo Sandron, 1-27.
Unstructured Citation
Pantaleoni M. [1914] 1917a. “Deficit„ più morale che finanziario. In Pantaleoni M. Note in margine della Guerra. Bari, Gius. Laterza & Figli, 7-14.
Unstructured Citation
Pantaleoni M. [1915] 1917b. I violenti. In Pantaleoni M. Note in margine della Guerra. Bari, Gius. Laterza & Figli, 57-62.
Unstructured Citation
Pantaleoni M. [1917] 1919a. L’erede di Orlando. In Pantaleoni M. La fine provvisoria di un’epopea. Bari, Gius. Laterza & Figli, 257-312.
Unstructured Citation
Pantaleoni M. [1918] 1919b. Caos e programmi del dopo-guerra. In Pantaleoni M. La fine provvisoria di un’epopea. Bari, Gius. Laterza & Figli, 85-103.
Unstructured Citation
Pantaleoni M. [1920] 1922a. Una causa della crisi italiana. In Pantaleoni M. Bolcevismo Italiano. Bari, Gius. Laterza & Figli, 25-48.
Unstructured Citation
Pantaleoni M. [1921] 1922b. Il controllo operaio delle industrie. In Pantaleoni M. Bolcevismo Italiano. Bari, Gius. Laterza & Figli, 101-132.
Unstructured Citation
Pantaleoni M. [1921] 1922c. Plutocrazia e Bolcevismo giudaico sgretolano il Fascismo. In Pantaleoni M. Bolcevismo italiano, Bari, Gius. Laterza & Figli, 207-219.
Unstructured Citation
Pantaleoni M. [1921] 1936. La situazione economica e le condizioni per un risanamento. In Pantaleoni M. Studi storici di economia. Bologna, Nicola Zanichelli Editore, 487-502.
Unstructured Citation
Pantaleoni M. 1882. Teoria della traslazione dei tributi: definizione, dinamica e ubiquità della traslazione. Rome, Tipografia di Adolfo Paolini.
Unstructured Citation
Pantaleoni M. 1889. Principii di economia pura. Florence, G. Barbèra.
Unstructured Citation
Pantaleoni M. 1894. Principii di economia pura. Seconda edizione. Florence, G. Barbèra.
Unstructured Citation
Pantaleoni M. 1902. La legislazione sociale e la democrazia. Giornale degli economisti, 25, 67-83.
Unstructured Citation
Pantaleoni M. 1911. Considerazioni sulle proprietà di un sistema di prezzi politici (Comunicazione fatta al Congresso dell’Associazione per il Progresso delle Scienze in Napoli). Giornale degli economisti, 42, 9-29, 114-138.
Unstructured Citation
Pantaleoni M. 1917c. Il congresso catilinario. In Pantaleoni M. Note in margine della Guerra. Bari, Gius. Laterza & Figli, 72-73.
Unstructured Citation
Pantaleoni M. 1922d. Prefazione. In Pantaleoni M. Bolcevismo Italiano. Bari, Gius. Laterza & Figli, III-XLVIII.
Unstructured Citation
Pareto V. [1891] 1974a. Socialismo e libertà. In Busino G. (ed.) Vilfredo Pareto œuvres complètes, XVII. Geneva, Librairie DROZ, 376-409.
Unstructured Citation
Pareto V. [1896] 1964a. Cours d’économie politique, Tome premier. In Bousquet G. H. and Busino G. (eds.) Vilfredo Pareto œuvres complètes, I. Geneva, Librairie DROZ, I-VIII, 1-430.
Unstructured Citation
Pareto V. [1897] 1964b. Cours d’économie politique, Tome second. In Bousquet G. H. and Busino G. (eds.) Vilfredo Pareto œuvres complètes, I. Geneva, Librairie DROZ, 1-426.
Unstructured Citation
Pareto V. [1898] 1965a. L’état actuel de l’Italie. In Busino G. (ed.) Vilfredo Pareto œuvres complètes, IV. Geneva, Librairie DROZ, 277-295.
Unstructured Citation
Pareto V. [1898] 1970. Encore quelque faits. In Busino G. (ed.) Vilfredo Pareto œuvres complètes, XIV. Gevneva, Librairie DROZ, 110-124.
Unstructured Citation
Pareto V. [1900] 1982a. Sunto di alcuni capitoli di un nuovo trattato di economia pura. In Busino G. (ed.) Vilfredo Pareto œuvres complètes, XXVI. Geneva, Librairie DROZ, 365-423.
Unstructured Citation
Pareto V. [1901] 1974b. Gli scioperi e il ministero Giolitti. In Busino G. (ed.) Vilfredo Pareto œuvres complètes, XVIII. Geneva, Librairie DROZ, 356-364.
Unstructured Citation
Pareto V. [1902] 1965b. Les systèmes socialistes, Tome premier. In Busino G. (ed.) Vilfredo Pareto œuvres complètes, V. Geneva, Librairie DROZ, 1-406.
Unstructured Citation
Pareto V. [1902] 1984a. Nouvelles castes sociales. In Busino G. (ed.) Vilfredo Pareto œuvres complètes, VI. Geneva, Librairie DROZ, 204-206.
Unstructured Citation
Pareto V. [1903] 1965c. Les systèmes socialistes, Tome second. In Busino G. (ed.) Vilfredo Pareto œuvres complètes, V. Geneva, Librairie DROZ, 1-492.
Unstructured Citation
Pareto V. [1903] 1984b. Le droit de grève. In Busino G. (ed.) Vilfredo Pareto œuvres complètes, VI. Geneva, Librairie DROZ, 216-218.
Unstructured Citation
Pareto V. [1903] 1984c. L’ordre dans les grèves. In Busino G. (ed.) Vilfredo Pareto œuvres complètes, VI. Geneva, Librairie DROZ, 240-242.
Unstructured Citation
Pareto V. [1904] 1984d. Épilogue des émeutes d’Armentières. In Busino G. (ed.) Vilfredo Pareto œuvres complètes, VI. Geneva, Librairie DROZ, 248-249.
Unstructured Citation
Pareto V. [1908] 1982b. Economia sperimentale. In Busino G. (ed.) Vilfredo Pareto œuvres complètes, XXVI. Geneva, Librairie DROZ, 626-643.
Unstructured Citation
Pareto V. [1909] 1981. Manuel d’économie politique,1re édition française. In Busino G. (ed.) Vilfredo Pareto œuvres completes, VII. Geneva, Librairie DROZ, 1-696.
Unstructured Citation
Pareto V. [1910] 1974c. Le mie idee. In Busino G. (ed.) Vilfredo Pareto œuvres complètes, XVIII. Geneva, Librairie DROZ, 480-483.
Unstructured Citation
Pareto V. [1911] 1980a. Redditieri e speculatori. In Busino G. (ed.) Vilfredo Pareto œuvres complètes, XXII. Geneva, Librairie DROZ, 416-424.
Unstructured Citation
Pareto V. [1920] 1980b. Fatti e teorie. In Busino G. (ed.) Vilfredo Pareto œuvres complètes, XXII. Geneva, Librairie DROZ, 593-915.
Unstructured Citation
Pareto V. [1921] 1967. Le chômage. In Busino G. (ed.) Vilfredo Pareto œuvres complètes, X. Geneva, Librairie DROZ, 170-173.
Unstructured Citation
Pareto V. [1921] 1980c. La trasformazione della democrazia. In Busino G. (ed.) Vilfredo Pareto œuvres complètes, XXII, Geneva. Librairie DROZ, 917-1059.
Unstructured Citation
Pareto V. [1922] 1974d. La crisi del risparmio. In Busino G. (ed.) Vilfredo Pareto œuvres completes, XVIII. Geneva, Librairie DROZ, 729-732.
Unstructured Citation
Pareto V. [1923] 1980d. Il fenomeno del fascismo. In Busino G. (ed.) Vilfredo Pareto œuvres complètes, XXII. Geneva, Librairie DROZ, 1168-1173.
Unstructured Citation
Pareto V. 1923a. Trattato di sociologia generale, Volume I. Florence, G. Barbèra.
Unstructured Citation
Pareto V. 1923b. Trattato di sociologia generale, Volume III. Florence, G. Barbèra.
Unstructured Citation
Quaranta B. (ed.) 1923. Mussolini as Revealed in His Political Speeches (November 1914-August1923). London and Toronto, J.M. Dent & Sons.
Unstructured Citation
Walras L. 1988. Éléments d’économie politique pure. In Dockès P. et al. (eds.) Auguste et Léon Walras œuvres économiques complètes, VIII. Paris, Economica, 1-737.